Neuroscience

When Twins Differ in Cannabis Use, How Do Their IQ Scores Compare?

·

Twins completing separate assessments in a research testing room.

Suppose two teenagers finish a vocabulary test three points apart. One has used cannabis and the other never has. It makes a considerable difference whether those teenagers first met in the examination room or shared a bedroom growing up. It makes an even bigger difference if someone thought to give them a vocabulary test before either had ever tried cannabis.

Nicholas Jackson and colleagues had access to both kinds of comparison. Their study of two American twin cohorts followed children into late adolescence, collecting cognitive test scores and asking about marijuana use. In the full groups, adolescents who used marijuana tended to lose ground on measures of acquired verbal knowledge relative to those who abstained. Then the researchers made a narrower comparison. When one twin had used marijuana and the other had abstained, they found no significant difference in IQ change between the two.

What a pair of twins brings to the comparison

A child learns the meanings of words through years of reading, conversation and schooling. Some families have easier access to books, stable housing and uninterrupted schooling than others. Family circumstances might also influence the chances that a teenager will try cannabis. A difference in scores between unrelated teenagers can therefore reflect influences that were at work years before anyone answered a question about drug use.

Comparing twins raised together holds much of that family background in common. Identical twins also share essentially all their inherited DNA, while fraternal twins share, on average, about half their segregating genetic variation. The question becomes unusually specific. Within families where exposure differs, does the sibling who used cannabis show a steeper decline on the tests? Jackson’s team saw little support for that prediction. They also found no consistent pattern in which greater reported marijuana use tracked with greater IQ decline.

A score at eighteen has a history

An independent study in England and Wales illustrates the value of the earliest test. Madeline Meier and colleagues had IQ measurements at ages five, twelve and eighteen. At eighteen, adolescents who used cannabis had lower IQ scores, on average. But differences could also be seen in childhood. An eighteen-year-old’s answer to a questionnaire could hardly explain a test score recorded years before that young person first used cannabis.

The British team also examined executive functions, including tasks that required participants to hold or manipulate information briefly. On five of six measures, the twin who used cannabis more frequently performed much like the other twin. There was an exception on a task requiring a sequence of spatial positions to be recalled in reverse. That detail is worth keeping. A vocabulary score, an overall IQ estimate and a test of working memory answer different questions, even when newspapers file them all under intelligence.

Where the comparison runs out

Twins have separate lives. One might miss more school, sleep poorly, join a different group of friends or use another substance. Such differences survive the family comparison. Self-reports introduce uncertainty too. Two teenagers classified as users may have had very different exposures. Restricting an analysis to pairs whose habits diverged also leaves fewer people with whom to detect a small effect, especially if the question concerns sustained heavy use.

Timing matters even when the test itself is identical. A review of cognitive studies in adolescents and young adults found that the length of abstinence required before testing helped explain differences across studies. Testing memory soon after use and tracking age-adjusted vocabulary scores over several years are distinct investigations. A study following young people through a month of abstinence, for example, could test changes in verbal learning over weeks. The twins’ childhood test papers serve a different purpose.

The informative result is the change in the comparison itself. A difference visible across families largely faded when the researchers followed scores within families. That finding gives shared background a larger role in the explanation and weakens the claim that marijuana alone produced the observed group difference. To learn when two adolescents began to diverge, the most revealing piece of evidence may be the test they took as children.